I Don't Love You (Part 2)

1-800-Bridesmaid

📞 Hello? Hi. It’s me, Jen Glantz. Welcome to the Bridesmaid for Hire Hotline. A place where real stories are shared and your best advice is given.

This week: Today we continue to read about a bride-to-be whose fiance is in the friend zone.

Hold please:

• Press 1️⃣ for all things Bridesmaid for Hire

• Press 2️⃣ to read past stories

• Press 3️⃣ to call the Bridesmaid for Hire hotline. Anonymously share your wedding, bridesmaid, friendship, relationship, and love problems and the readers will give you our unbiased advice.

  Ps. This is the free version of the newsletter. For $5/month get access to endless perks: access to a private community, bonus posts, and more.

  ---

  💔I Don't Love You (Part 2)

  Last time we chatted, I shared the story of the bride who confessed to me, 3-months before her wedding, that she had rapidly untwisted out of love. She wasn’t so sure Seth, the guy she was about to marry, was the guy she wanted to be with forever. 

  We talked about this a lot. We picked apart the meaning of the love, her fears about the future, and the list of things about Seth that kept making her break out into hives.

  On the night she finally told Seth that she wasn’t feeling the feels for him anymore, I got a knock on my door, and there he was, at my house, all alone.

  I didn’t open the door at first because I was scared and also in shock. How did he know where I lived? We had met three times before, with the bride there, but mostly in public places. She had been to my apartment once, a few months back, to try on dresses for her rehearsal dinner. 

  I pretended I wasn’t home but kept my eye on the peephole. Suddenly, when I looked closer, to the left was the bride. She was there too.

  I unlocked my door, pulled it open, and showed my teeth.

  “Jen,” she started saying. “He knows everything.”

  “Everything?” I shot back.

  “Everything,” he answered.

Read more stories • Say Hello on TikTok • Grab the Book

I learned in my gig as a hired bridesmaid that silence helps more than rambling does. This is a life lesson not so easy for a blabbermouth like myself who dreads awkward silence. But at that moment, I crossed my arms and buckled my lips.

Until I just couldn’t take it anymore.

“And???” I asked, expecting an explanation and an apology for showing up at my door on a Friday night.

[Note to self: I don’t charge clients enough moment for moments like these.]

“And he sort of feels the same,” she said. “But...”

“But?” I said.

“He wants to go through with the wedding anyway.”

It turned out, Seth was catching the vibes the bride was tossing his way. He knew that she wasn't into him anymore but he didn’t know how to bring that up to her. Now that the wedding was less than 29 days away, he wanted to go through with the wedding. He didn’t want everyone in his life to know the truth -- yet.

She felt the same. Canceling the party, losing $80,000, and having to listen to friends and family tell her how sorry they were for her broken engagement just seemed daunting.

They were at my door asking permission to have the wedding with a fake marriage.

A few times before this same thing has happened. A couple didn’t want to end their engagement so close to the wedding that they went through with it. Some didn’t sign the marriage license and some did but got divorced later on. 

I told them that calling it off would hurt their bank account but wouldn’t be the end of the world if that’s what they wanted.

“We don’t want that,” they said.

They seemed on the same page, content, thrilled.

“Well then, okay. Do what you want and I will be there.”

And I was there...on their wedding day.

When people find out I’m a hired bridesmaid, they think I zip on a dress, hug a bunch of people I don’t know, and walk down the aisle with a smile on my face.

What they don’t see are the secrets stuffed inside of my brain and the guilt safety pinned onto my heart.

I’ve seen so much on the job that doesn’t resemble love in any way shape or form. 

Sometimes I’m by someone’s side for the happiest day of their life and other times I’m by someone’s side for the toughest day of their life. You wouldn’t know that because when it comes time to say I do, people do. They kiss, they smile, they walk side-by-side, and they turn to me and wink.

The secret hired bridesmaid who showed up and did what they wanted, even if it’s not what I would have wanted them to do in the first place.

All my love,

Jen Glantz 

---

👗 Wedding Guest Outfits under $100:

👏 This dress is under $60 and seriously fits so well. I have it in my closet for holiday parties, weddings, and wore it on vacation once too. 

👠 I've tried on lots of shoes and this brand is usually pretty comfy.  

📝 My other newsletter is a burst of motivation to help you feel good on Monday mornings. 

📚 I'm super proud of this book. It's on-sale for the holidays and a cozy little read. 

🎵 A fun pump-up playlist

🎁 If you're looking for a gift for the couple getting married that's more uncommon.

👏 We were featured in The NY Times! The article features our maid of honor/best man speech and vow writing tools. 

👏 Wedding Guest Outfits:

Off the shoulder look

October dress

Cocktail hour pick

November gown

A fun printed dress

My favorite jumpsuit if you're over dresses

👠Sharing shoes that are great for the dance floor – or just every day errands.

Silver sneakers

Good price and comes in different colors

Classic pair of shoes

In style now

Good sandals for a wedding dance floor

---

👋 Hire a Bridesmaid • Speech + Vows • Shop the Picks • Start Your Own Wedding Biz

📞Call the Bridesmaid for Hire Hotline • Subscribe • Browse our website

Why you're getting this:

I'm Jen Glantz and this is my Bridesmaid for Hire newsletter.

If you want to stop getting emails from us, we understand. You can hit the unsubscribe button below.